Row over 'mocking' of disabled MP deepens

Published by Ross Macmillan for 24dash.com in Local Government and also in Central Government, Communities

The row over the alleged mocking of an MP with cerebral palsy deepened today after a Labour MP attacked the "unsubstantiated claims".

Tory Paul Maynard sparked outrage last week after accusing Labour MPs of pulling faces and stretching their cheeks while he spoke in the House, in an apparent attempt to mimic him.

The backlash today led Lib Dem Greg Mulholland to demand a debate on MPs' behaviour in the Commons.

But Labour's Ian Murray said he was "deeply concerned" the matter had been raised - and asked Speaker John Bercow for guidance.

Raising a point of order, Mr Murray (Edinburgh South) added: "Could you give us some guidance on whether you run this chamber or the media?"

Mr Murray was angered by Mr Mulholland's plea for a debate following Mr Maynard's interview with The Times where he spoke of his distress as he addressed MPs during a debate on the Child Trust Fund.

The Tory (Blackpool N and Cleveleys) told the paper: "They (some Labour MPs) were constantly intervening, trying to put me off my stride, which may be just normal parliamentary tactics.

"But some were pulling faces at me, really exaggerated gesticulations, really exaggerated faces.

"Only they know for certain whether they were taking the mick out of my disability - but it felt like it."

Mr Mulholland (Leeds NW) pointed out Labour MPs' excuse that "had they have known about the disability, they would not have done it", did not pardon their behaviour.

He said today: "The inference is they feel mimicry, face-pulling (and) jeering is acceptable. It is not and let's stamp it out."

Leader of the House Sir George Young replied: "Members on all sides will condemn the way he (Mr Maynard) was treated when he made that speech on Child Trust Funds.

"I very much hope there will be no recurrence."

Sir George, speaking during Business Questions, said responsibility for MPs' behaviour in the House lay with the Speaker.

Mr Bercow said: "I am in charge in the chamber. I am aware of the matters referred to and I have made some public comment.

"It has also been the subject of private discussions, but I want to leave it at that."