Brown engages in class warfare as Cameron forced on the defensive
Other Central Government stories
- Landlord to revive council's housing PFI scheme
- Five councils to share homelessness services
- Peers urged to find new exemption to 'bedroom tax'
- New anti-social behaviour triggers 'unlikely to solve worst cases'
- Stalled site cash earmarked for London borough's largest housing estate
Advertisement
According to the Duke of Wellington, Waterloo was won on the
playing fields of Eton. If Gordon Brown gets his way the English
public school will be the battleground for the coming next general
election.
Prime Ministers questions today degenerated into raw political
knockabout in which Mr Brown retreated to his comfort zone of class
warfare, notably mocking David Cameron's public school
background.
Mr Brown was back on the offensive after a difficult couple of
weeks for Mr Cameron. The clunking fist, which for months has
appeared to have lacked any force, was back in action, landing
blows on the Tories.
After getting his facts wrong the previous week over two Islamic
schools - which resulted in an embarrassing apology to the Commons
on Monday - Mr Cameron chose to confront Mr Brown on the safer
ground of the economy.
With Britain still mired in recession, while major competitor
countries are growing again, Mr Cameron had plenty of ammunition.
He mocked Mr Brown's boastful claims that he was leading the world
out of recession, that Britain had been better prepared for the
downturn, as well as his now infamous claim to have abolished "boom
and bust".
Such attacks just seem to bounce off Mr Brown, who ignores
questions he does not like and ploughs on regardless.
Instead, he seized on the disclosure at the weekend that Zac
Goldsmith, the environmentalist and Conservative candidate for
Richmond Park, had retained the non-domiciled tax status he
inherited from his father, the billionaire Sir James Goldsmith.
Being a "non-dom" meant he did not pay tax on offshore
income.
The subsequent announcement that Mr Goldsmith had relinquished his
non-dom status came too late to save Mr Cameron's blushes at
question time. The Downing Street wordsmiths are certainly coming
up with better one-liners than the Cameron team.
For Labour, the row over Mr Goldsmith's non-dom status was the
perfect political storm - bringing together wealth and privilege,
the old Etonian background of Mr Cameron and Mr Goldsmith, and Tory
plans to raise the inheritance tax threshold to £1
million.
After all, the proposed Tory cut in inheritance tax is to be funded
by a £25,000-a-year tax charge on non-doms - and Mr Cameron
is reputed to have more old Etonians around him than any leader
since Macmillan.
Mr Brown's parting jibe to the Tory leader was that his tax
policies appeared to have been "dreamt up on the playing field of
Eton".
The unedifying and rowdy Commons exchanges, with the new Speaker,
John Bercow, struggling to keep order, added little to the sum of
human knowledge. But they showed how Mr Brown is developing a
political strategy to counter the Tories at the next
election.
It will concentrate on attacking "Tory Toffs". That line of attack
backfired in last year's Crewe and Nantwich by-election, but Mr
Brown believes the recession has sharpened the class divide and
that message will now resonate with the voters.
He is paving the way for a reprise of Labour's successful "for the
many not the few" campaign which swept the Tories out of power in
1997. As he put it today: "Public services for the many versus
inheritance tax cuts for the few."
Central to the Labour campaign will be the accusation that despite
Mr Cameron's attempts to modernise his party and present a new
moderate image, he is still proposing tax cuts for the better off
and austerity for the rest.
Mr Brown gave a foretaste of that onslaught, saying that while Mr
Cameron might project the "voice of the modern public relations
man" he had the "mindset of the 1930s".
He hopes voters will recoil from Tory warnings of spending cuts,
preferring Labour's claim that growth is the way to tackle the
deficit.
Significantly Mr Brown sidestepped a challenge from Mr Cameron to
confirm that Labour would go ahead with its own increase in the
inheritance tax threshold from £325,000 to £350,000
next year.
There has been recent speculation that it will be shelved in next
week's pre-Budget Report in order to highlight the political divide
with the Tories.
The Conservative pledge has already been downgraded as an objective
to be achieved by the end of a first Tory government. Given the
recession and the need for public spending cuts, some Tories would
like it shelved altogether.
But after abandoning his "cast iron" promise to hold a referendum
on the Lisbon Treaty, Mr Cameron is reluctant to open himself up to
further accusations of a U-turn on a flagship policy.
These are testing times for the Tories. Mr Cameron appears to have
lost his surefootedness, with embarrassing stumbles and mistakes
while Mr Brown has regained his self-confidence.
A clutch of recent opinion polls suggests the gap is narrowing
between Labour and the Tories - raising speculation of a hung
parliament. Labour remains in deep trouble, but Mr Brown is
nurturing hopes that he could still deny Mr Cameron an overall
majority.
A week let alone six months is a long time in politics. After
today, there will be more jangling nerves in Tory HQ than in No
10.
The UK's most up-to-date social housing and public sector news website
